Reviews for Academic Stream - Full & Short Papers (Oral Presentation)
Thank you for supporting iLRN’s peer review process. Your careful and ethical evaluation ensures a high standard of research in immersive learning. Please review each submission fairly, confidentially, and professionally, using the criteria provided in the review form while following established international ethical guidelines listed below. The review form is embedded in EasyChair (have a look at this page to see how to add your review).
Paper Type
Please consider the paper type when reviewing. You can find more information on the Academic Stream on this website: https://codex.immersivelrn.org/books/instructions-for-authors/page/academic-stream-submissions
Full paper
- 12-
1515+ pages, incl. references - Springer LNCS template
- for oral presentation
Comprehensive reports of research, development, and application of immersive learning and technologies. Oral presentations might include live recording and global distribution. Online presentations will include publication and distribution of a pre-recorded video.
Short paper
- 8-11 pages, incl. references
- Springer LNCS template
- for oral presentation
Concise reports or preliminary findings of ongoing research on immersive learning/technologies. Oral presentations might include live recording and global distribution. Online presentations will include publication and distribution of a pre-recorded video.
What to Evaluate
In the EasyChair form, please provide ratings on:
-
ContributionContribution to Immersive Learning Research (weight: 1)
- When evaluating the project at its current phase of development: How much does the submission (potentially) contribute to research on learning, instruction, teaching or education with immersive technologies?
- Please keep in mind that the scope of the conference includes research on learning (education/teaching/training/instruction/...) WITH immersive technology (VR/AR/XR/MR/games/360°...), so both components should be clearly included in the submission.
- Please also check if the submission fits well to the
topictrack that it was submitted to. Otherwise please suggest a better fitting topic (https://www.codex.immersivelrn.org/ilrn2026/call-books/instructions-for-papers/#program-tracksauthors/page/academic-stream-submissions)). Justify your review in the field "Comments for the Authors" below. Originality and innovationHow original and innovative is this contribution? How novel and unique are the proposed approach, methods, or ideas?Justify your review by providing constructive feedback to the authors to improve their contribution in the field"Commentsbelow.
for the Authors" below.- Originality
Methodologicalandor theoretical rigorDepending on the type of contributioninnovation (empiricalweight:or1)theoretical):- How
soundoriginal and innovative isthe research methodology or theoretical contribution ofthissubmission?contribution? - How
empiricalnovelwork:and unique are theexperimental(proposed)design,approach,datamethods,collection,orand analysis appropriate and well-executed? For theoretical work: are theoretical conclusions logically structured and coherent? Justify your review by providing constructive feedback to the proposal submitters to improve their contribution in the field "Comments for the Authors" below.ideas? Validity and significance of claims and conclusionsHow valid, significant and appropriate are the claims and/or conclusion the authors make? Do they interpret and discuss the implications of their empirical results/theoretical conclusions and (if applicable) the limitations of their work?Justify your review by providing constructive feedback to the authors to improve their contribution in the field"Commentsbelow.
Forfor the Authors" below. - How
- Methodological/theoretical
Qualityrigor (weight: 2)- Depending on the type of
writingcontribution (empirical or theoretical) andacademicwhenstyle
Isevaluating thetextprojecterroratfreeits(spelling,currentsyntax,phasegrammar)?ofIsdevelopment: How sound, comprehensive and robust is thetext(proposed)comprehensibleresearchtomethodology or theoretical contribution of this submission? - Depending on the type of
- For empirical work: are the
academicexperimentalcommunity?design, data collection methods, and analysis appropriate and well-planned or executed? - For theoretical work: are theoretical framework or conclusions solidly grounded and logically coherent?
- Justify your review by providing constructive feedback to the authors to improve their contribution in the field
"Commentsbelow.
for the Authors" below. - Claims/Conclusions,
AnchoringLimitations,inand/orrelevantExpected Outcomes (weight: 1)- Depending on the type of contribution (empirical or theoretical) and when evaluating the project at its current
literature
wellsound, comprehensive and robust is thepaper anchored in relevant immersive learning(proposed) researchliterature?methodologyDoesorittheoreticalprovidecontribution of this submission? - Depending on the type of contribution (empirical or theoretical) and when evaluating the project at its current
- For empirical work: are the experimental design, data collection methods, and analysis appropriate
citationandofwell-plannedrelatedorworkexecuted? - For
thetheoreticalfield?work: are theoretical framework or conclusions solidly grounded and logically coherent? - Justify your review by providing constructive feedback to the authors to improve their contribution in the field
"Commentsbelow.
and academic writing style (weight: 1)
- Is the text error free (spelling, syntax, grammar)? Is the text comprehensible to the academic community?
- Optional: If you want, you can add explanations in the text box.
- How well is the paper anchored in relevant immersive learning research literature?
- Does it provide appropriate citation of related work in the field?
- Optional: If you want, you can add explanations in the text box.
- Does the paper comply with the
Springer LNCS templatetemplates and guidelines(as described here https://www.springer.com/gp/computer-science/lncs/conference-proceedings-guidelines/)codex.immersivelrn.org/books/instructions-for-authors/page/academic-stream-submissions? - Optional:
yourIfreviewyoubywant,providingyouconstructivecanfeedbackaddto the authors to improve their contributionexplanations in thefieldtext"Commentsbox.
If helpful, recommend a more appropriate paper category to support the authors.Category
- Which category would be most appropriate for this paper? Would you recommend the author/s to submit a revised version of the paper to another category? The author/s will be required to revise their paper as necessary to comply with the relevant page limits, and the paper will be reviewed again.
- Optional: If you want, you can add explanations in the text box.
(weight: 3)
- Please provide the overall evaluation for the submission. Should it be accepted for presentation at iLRN2027 and publication in the conference
proceedingsproceedings? - For all categories, revisions of papers based on the reviewers' comments should be made.
- Justify your
reviewoverall evaluation by providing constructive feedback to the authors to improve their contribution in the field "Comments for the Authors" below. - Comments for authors:
- Please summarize your ratings and how you got to the overall evaluation.
- Point out the strengths and weaknesses of the submission and provide constructive suggestions for improvement.
- Clear and detailed feedback should be provided, even if you are of the view the submission should not be accepted for the conference.
- You can refer back to comments that you already made above.
Constructive, Ethical & Objective Review
iLRN adheres to recognized peer-review ethics. Reviewers are expected to follow:
- COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers https://publicationethics.org/resources/guidelines-new/cope-ethical-guidelines-peer-reviewers
- iLRN Publications Ethics & Malpractice Statement (Reviewers’ Responsibilities) https://www.immersivelrn.org/about/publications-ethics-and-malpractice-statement/
- Springer Nature Reviewer Guidelines https://www.springer.com/gp/editorial-policies/peer-review-policy-process
Your comments to authors should:
-
Explain and justify all ratings
-
Identify strengths and weaknesses
-
Offer specific, actionable suggestions
-
Use a respectful, unbiased, and professional tone
--> Do not include personal judgments or assumptions about author identity, background, location, or intent.
--> Maintain confidentiality - do not share, store externally, or reuse content.
--> Do not upload manuscripts into generative AI tools, per COPE and Springer Nature policies.
Evidence-Based Evaluation
For empirical contributions:
-
Clear research questions and rationale
-
Appropriate methodology and execution
-
Transparent reporting of results, limitations, and implications
For theoretical/conceptual contributions:
-
Logical and coherent argumentation
-
Grounding in recognized scholarly literature
-
Clear advancement of conceptual understanding in the field
Evaluate only what is presented in the manuscript.
Literature & Research Integrity
Assess whether:
-
Prior work in immersive learning research (i.e. prior ILRN conference proceedings) is properly cited
-
The contribution is clearly contextualized within the field
-
Citation practices meet academic integrity norms
If you suspect plagiarism, fabricated data, ethical issues or unreported AI use:
→ Report concerns via Confidential feedback to the program committee only.
Overall Recommendation
When rating acceptance suitability:
-
Consider both the importance of the contribution and the feasibility of revisions
-
Ensure alignment between ratings, recommendation, and review narrative
-
Even when recommending rejection, include constructive feedback to help the authors improve
Reviewer Confidence & Confidential Notes
- Indicate your true level of expertise in the confidence field
-
Use confidential notes only for communication with Program Committee Chairs (not to authors)
Award Nominations
Nominate a paper only if it demonstrates:
-
Outstanding rigor, originality, clarity, and impact
-
Clear potential to advance immersive learning research
Thank You!
Your thoughtful review contributes to:
-
Excellence in scholarly publication
-
A fair and supportive academic review culture
-
Growth and advancement of the immersive learning community
For any questions related to ethics or review standards, please reach out to the iLRN2026 Program Chairs or the iLRN Scientific Quality Assurance Team.